Luis Barragán's Plaza
de la Revolución
with bench and
concrete umbrella.
Barragán concrete
bench with room
for storage.
Jose Bedia,
Invictus, 1996,
at A/B/S Projects.
Annina Nosei's
booth, with works
by Galan, Teresa
Serrano and
Arturo Elizondo.
Megan Williams,
Three Seats, 1994, at
Christopher Grimes.
Mary-Anne Martin,
center, on top
of things.
Jose Clemente Orozco,
Still Life, 1944,
at Enrique Guerrero.
At the fair (from
right), Lorna Simpson
and Andrea Rosen.
A Mexican icon:
Posada's Death as
a Noveaux Riche
Old Lady.
Lorna Simpson,
Bill Arning and
Paolo Colombo.
Lola Alvarez
Bravo at
Throckmorton.
A farewell smile:
Senegalese curator
Eri Camara.
guadalajara buzz
by Eduardo Costa
As the art world was gearing up for its
new fall season, the Mexican city of
Guadalajara was playing host to the
international cutting-edge art fair
Expoarte, Sept. 26-30, 1996. Now in its
fifth year, Expoarte is better than ever,
with 57 galleries from 13 countries
exhibiting work by approximately 400
artists. Most of the work on view was very
good. By my estimates, 80 percent of the
stuff rated from acceptable to great, while
20 percent ranged from mediocre to
depressing--just the opposite of Miami's
art fair.
And how was this achieved? Well, the
organizers were selective, making
Guadalajara a curated fair. Plus the site
helped, with its airy spaces, cool cement
floors and simple white partitions. It also
helped that the fair was accompanied by
symposia that included several art "big
heads." The thinking crowd can be counted
to add seriousness and sometimes drama to
the event--last year the veteran Italian
critic and Venice Biennale curator Achille
Bonito Oliva, under heavy attack from the
French organizer of Documenta, Catherine
David, smashed the microphone against the
floor. This year, curator Claudia Madrazo
took the microphone to announce that she
only cared to speak to three people in the
audience, hence the others could leave--and
most of them did. And then there was the
crowd--a quotient of invited artists,
curators with their parallel shows and, of
course, the collectors.
The host city is right for the event as
well. Guadalajara has always guarded its
traditions while at the same time investing
in what proved to be superb premonitions of
the art to come. Remember the great Mexican
muralist José Clemente Orozco? A native of
Guadalajara, he was trusted with huge
commissions that he produced in wildly
site-specific versions. For instance,
Orozco murals rule the walls of the Main
Chapel of the Cabañas, an old, fabulous
mental hospital turned government building,
which served as the reception center for
the art fair. As Paolo Colombo, the
director of Geneva's Center for
Contemporary Art, put it, "They brought me
straight from the airport to this
incredible art, and they gave me drinks."
Instead of benches, the Chapel has large
banquettes for people to lie on their backs
and look up at the murals.
Another Guadalajara native was architect
Luis Barragán. Some of his houses from the
1930s are open to visitors, and one of his
parks, the Plaza de la Revolución, is an
urban oasis that blends tropical vegetation
with original benches, fountains and calmly
twisting paths. A local poet, Víctor Ortiz,
took me to the park. There is a saying in
Guadalajara that goes, "The tree that grows
up twisted will be bought by Barragán."
With this kind of esthetic thinking a
commonplace, it's no wonder that Expoarte's
new imagination felt right at home.
Lodging was in central Guadalajara, near
the great plazas and colonial buildings.
Coming in by taxi from the airport I saw
the famous roses--Guadalajara is also known
as the City of the Roses. These large roses
are different than any other, seeming to
float in mid air, since the bushes have
very few leaves. A shuttle bus would take
everybody out to the fair in the morning,
and bring us all back that evening. On my
first commute, I happened to sit next to
Lorna Simpson, and 30 minutes of intense
conversation followed. She was very happy
with her new work (photographs printed on
felt, mostly about making love in public
places), and we also discussed African
religions, family life, gender tensions as
they occur among us and in other cultures.
The chat was a great example of the
camaraderie that permeated the fair
experience.
As is usual with such events, opening
ceremonies for the fair on Sept. 26 were
marked by speeches, delivered by Mr.
Schmidhuber, who is the Secretary of
Culture of Jalisco State, as well as by
Pablo del Val, organizer of the fair. At
one point I saw the French art star Orlan
proudly displaying her scarifications.
These embellishments are rather Star Trek,
a pair of skin elevations in the form of
croissants about three centimeters long
each that decorate the area on top and to
the sides of her eyebrows. Orlan's work has
consisted mostly of radical plastic
surgery, in which she has had her face
remade to look like the faces of certain
classic art works, among them the Mona
Lisa. She has the operations photographed
and then sells the lacerating evidence. In
Japan in the year 2000, Orlan is scheduled
to build on her face a flesh and bone nose
stemming from mid-forehead and sticking out
some 8 centimeters. I met Orlan last year,
at my Thanksgiving party, and already she
had in mind to celebrate the new millennium
with this piece. She honestly believes her
work is blasphemous. I don't think the gods
are very worried about it, but she should
probably be, since she may not survive the
many defigurations needed to keep people
talking. In any case, Orlan was intelligent
and provocative at the symposia, vibrating
always with a mixture of talent and
despair.
As the fair went on, the parallel shows
opened. There were several, all of them
interesting, and it was great to circulate
from one to another. Among these, "Video Faz"
curated by Ruben Gallo and Terence Gower,
was a remarkable collection of 10
international video self-portraits and,
together with Opera's Videofiesta Quebec,
Canada, the only specific presentation of
the medium at Expoarte.
For Paris' Galerie Froment and Putman,
flying to Mexico paid big. They sold a
couple of small works and an important
piece by James Turrell. The piece is a
walk-in cabin where you put on a high-tech
helmet. Then you manipulate three dials to
send flashes of intense blue, yellow and
red light into your corneas. Who would buy
the optic nerve-stabbing, post-Mondrian
device? It seems a Mexican collector did,
for an undisclosed, and substantial,
amount.
Many gallerists reported sales. The
Brazilian dealer Marcantonio Vilaca said he
would come back next year whether he had
any sales or not--and by the end he had
closed some sales and said this was the
best fair he'd been to. Enrique Guerrero, on
the third day, hadn't sold anything but he
was sure at least three of his important
works would change hands in the next three
months, going to people who saw them at the
fair. Sandra Gering sold six works at
prices between $2,000 and $6,000, and was
very happy with the whole thing. And Annina
Nosei, with a disarming smile, said she had
sold a couple of important pieces and had
reserves on a couple more. On the third day
of the fair, Nina Menocal, an important
Mexican Gallery, had not sold anything. She
had very interesting work, and is
remarkably charming, but surmised that the
many invited collectors were entertained so
incessantly that they didn't have any
energy left for the art.
Other dealers also thought collectors should
spend more time looking at the work. OMR,
another important Mexican gallery, had sold
a few works in the $3,000-$5,000 range by
the fourth day. Christopher Grimes from Santa
Monica also was happy; he made good contacts
with other dealers, and sold five works at
prices ranging from $1,500 to $4,000. Andrea
Rosen was doing well with "Mexican, European
and American collectors," she said, but did
not volunteer details. George Adams of New
York, Fredric Snitzer of Coral Gables,
Fla., and Ramis Barquet from Mexico formed
an ad hoc group called A/B/S projects to
present work by José Bedia. They said they
sold three of the six paintings, measuring
9 x 6 ft., at around $18,000-$25,000 each.
In all, dealer's faces were quite relaxed
and you could even spot some smiles.
Although the fair was about the cutting
edge, some galleries showed Latin American
masters, to address what is seen as a
potential group of powerful local
collectors. Enrique Guerrero had a
wonderful selection of classics: Diego
Rivera's `54 Portrait of Lupita Cruz
($750,000), a really great volcanic
landscape by Siqueiros ($60,000), a superb
J.C. Orozco ($800,000), a Remedios Varo
(not for sale) and a `24 Rodríguez Lozano
($35,000). New York City's own Mary-Anne
Martin showed a great, medium-sized Leonora
Carrington, solid works by Orozco and
Rivera, and three intense and
characteristic Gunther Gerzso paintings
(prices ranging from $35,000 to $70,000.
Throckmorton Fine Arts presented the
classics of photography, including works by
Lola and Manuel Álvarez Bravo, Tina Modotti
and some wonderful period prints about a
century old (starting at $250).
The symposia took place in a three-day
stretch, with morning and afternoon
meetings. They were organized by Cuban
curator Osvaldo Sánchez. Although I missed
some of the meetings, what I caught was
quite substantial. Paolo Colombo elaborated
on the current crisis for many cash-starved
Kunshalles, which do not collect but rather
complement the museum role by providing a
kind of enlarged atelier for artists. Eri
Camara, a curator from Senegal and Mexico,
discussed the Disneyfication of culture--
like the Metropolitan with its many
boutiques around the world--and
multiculturalism as a prescription for the
market, since it's not enough to include
"the other" in Occidental narration. René
Cohelo, director of Amsterdam's Montevideo,
made a substantial presentation on media
art. Other participants were Lois Keidan
(London's ICA), Norman Batkin (Center for
Curatorial Studies at Bard), María del
Corral (Barcelona's Fundació La Caixa),
Bill Arning (writer and curator from NYC),
Carlos Aranda (Mexican curator), Ivo
Mezquita (Brazilian writer and curator),
Olivier Debroise (Mexican curator) and
Sabrine Beitwieser (Vienna's EA-Generali
Foundation).
And what would I buy? A number of things.
Among them Mona Hatoum's black-and-white
photograph of two feet walking as they drag
one boot tied to each ankle (at Chantal
Crousel); Lorna Simpsons "Nine Props," an
ensemble of lithographs on felt showing
nine vases which played minor roles in old
photos--subtly feminist and beautiful (at
Dorsky); Saint Clair Cemin's small
sculpture of a motherly looking mass of
hardly shaped marble and another,
separated, childlike mass, both connected
by a piece of wire undulating from the
mother's "breast" to the child's "mouth"
(at Ramis Barquet); Willie Doherty's
impressive shots of a site that was bombed
in Ireland, before the immediate clean-up
that always follows (at Flay and
Bourgeois); Liliana Porter's photograph of
two mini-dolls communicating on a field of
nothingness (at Ruth Benzacar); Helio
Oiticica's "Metaesquemas" paintings from
1957-58 (at Edelstein); John McCracken's
outrageously colored Minimal prism (Froment
& Putman); J.F. Herrán's five-foot-in-
diameter, thick carpet representing the CIA
logo (at Valenzuela y Klenner); Miguel
Ángel Ríos' living, red painting of a maguey
plant on green color field (at OMR);
Valeska Soares' pair of metal feet joined
by a long, thick, and red velvet rope (at
Camargo-Vilaca); and Ladrón de Guevara's
photographs of vanishing ayes (at Nina
Menocal.)
Other artists with interesting work on
view: Uli Aigner, William Anastasi, Luis
Benedit, Ashley Bickerton, Sophie Calle,
Nicola Constantino, Tony Cragg, Arturo
Duclós, Jeanne Dunning, Arturo Elizondo,
Julio Galán, Terence Gower, Silvia Gruner,
Jane Hammond, Katcho, Robert Kelly, Mike
Kelley, Patricia Landen, Laura London,
Chelo Matesanz, Iñigo Manglano Ovalle,
Cildo Meirelles, Ana Mendieta, Annette
Messanger, Yoko Ono, Tom Otterness, Raymond
Pettibon, Sigmar Polke, Richard Prince,
Cosimo Di Leo Ricatto, Elena del Rivero,
Daniela Rosell, Chéri Samba, Julian
Schnabel, Kiki Smith, Seton Smith, Valeska
Soares, Peter Sandbichler, Teresa Serrano,
Raymundo Sesma, Wolfgang Tillmans, Riskrit
Tiravanija, Boris Viskin, Jeff Wall, Nahum
Zenil and Andrea Zittel.
EDUARDO COSTA is a writer who lives and
works on the Internet.
|