Much too simple, doubtless. But such is the nature of the real….
Ought we not first learn to fly backward too, or stand still in the air like a hummingbird?
— Henry Miller
David Zwirner is pleased to present Stand still like the hummingbird,
an exhibition curated by Bellatrix Hubert in the gallery’s 525 and 533
spaces. It takes its title from a collection of short stories and essays
by American writer Henry Miller, published in 1962. Known equally
for his mysticism and dark humor, Miller proposed the idea of “flying
backwards, standing still like a hummingbird” as a lighthearted
antidote to the frantic pace of modern society.
In borrowing Miller’s title, the exhibition also embraces the paradox
at its heart: the hummingbird, of course, only appears inert because
we cannot visually process its wing beat quickly enough. Hubert has
gathered a careful selection of paintings, sculptures, and videos
by artists who engage with contradictions, impossibilities, and
the absurd. They also share a concern with understated gestures
and formal restraint, which finds its historical starting point in the
exhibition with Marcel Duchamp’s Comb (1916/1964). Along with the
artist’s other readymades from the early twentieth century, the gray steel comb signaled a dry, deadpan aesthetic, which
came to influence a century of art-making. The works in the show are subtle iterations of this lineage, their matter-of-factness
alternating between the poetic, funny, and unnerving.
Several works from the 1960s and 1970s, the decades where Duchamp gained renewed attention, provide apt examples of how
straightforward gestures can be used to yield complex outcomes. Forty-two postcards by On Kawara, stamped by the time he
got up on a given day and simply titled I Got Up (1968-1976), offer a map of the artist’s whereabouts that complement other
projects in documenting and archiving his existence. Gordon Matta-Clark’s installation, Hair (1972), likewise offers a belated
testament to the artist’s physical presence. Cut off on New Year’s Eve following a year of untamed growth, individual strands
of his hair were carefully mapped out, numbered according to a three-dimensional grid, and arranged in a wig formation.
Photographs document the ritualized performance like a taxonomy of change.
Other works forego reference to the personal altogether. They include Bernd and Hilla Becher’s Wassertürme (1967) and a
collection of Ed Ruscha’s photobooks (1964-1978), which follow systematic rules for presenting everyday objects in a neutral and objective manner. Mason Williams’s Bus Book (1967), a life-size, black-and-white silkscreen print of a Greyhound bus,
adds a trompe l’oeil dimension, but almost appears supernatural despite its candor. Its packaging in an unassuming, small
cardboard box seems part of an intricate, tongue-in-cheek ploy.
Christopher Williams’s three photographs from 2008 follow similar rules for industrial photography adhered to by
photographers such as the Bechers, but manipulate viewers’ expectations in the process. With lengthy titles that list the name
of the subject along with camera information, location, and details about the company that manufactured the subject’s shirt,
they wryly “collage” together elements from the history of photography. Rodney Graham’s classically composed photographs
of majestic oak trees shown upside-down play with the conventions of artistic representation while reminding us that the
image projected onto the retina is, in fact, inverted, and subsequently corrected by the brain (Welsh Oaks, 1998).
Duchamp’s legacy is explicitly invoked by Sherrie Levine, whose appropriation of iconic Walker Evans photographs stretch the
idea of the readymade to include existing artworks (After Walker Evans, 1981). The books and magazine cut-outs arranged
on shelves by Carol Bove likewise fall under the category of readymades, and here derive multi-layered meanings from their
careful composition next to one another.
Amongst the videos on view, two works by Morgan Fisher fuse the banal and the bizarre. In Red Boxing Gloves/Orange
Kitchen Gloves (1980), hands fondle kitchen and boxing gloves in soft motions that appear at once uncomfortable, erotic,
and comical; in Protective Coloration (1979), layers upon layers of colorful disguise—teeth guard, goggles, swimming caps—
gradually render Fisher unrecognizable as he silently faces the camera. A different type of uncanniness is provided in Bruce
Nauman’s Raw Material with Continuous Shift-MMMM (1991), which incorporates an upside-down, revolving self-portrait that
infers a sense of dizziness upon the viewer, while obstructing easy identification.
Francis Alÿs’s video Retoque/Painting (2008) shows him repainting by hand fading median strips on a road stretching across
the Panama Canal. This mechanical, disciplined act calls attention to the mobility of geographical borders and the obliteration
of territorial demarcations, while also presenting a tongue-in-cheek comment on the status of painting and the touch of the
artist. Christopher Williams’s 5 ½ hour long Supplement (2003) presents footage from a popular German cooking show without
any editing, thus showing seemingly interminable views of bubbling soups and toasts in the making (including a 50 minute
long view of a jelly dessert setting).
Abstract works in the exhibition, including paintings by Tomma Abts and Alan Uglow, handwoven linens by Ruth Laskey, and
a triangular column by John McCracken adhere to a minimal language while they are also curiously suggestive, playful, and
personal. Works by Cady Noland (Institutional Field, 1991) and Robert Gober (Untitled, 2000-2001) are balanced between
abstraction and representation: Noland’s metal fence placed flat on the ground becomes an eerie aesthetic form, while
Gober’s bronze cast of a block of Styrofoam presents a visual contrast between light and heavy, sculpture and pedestal.
Hubert curated the critically acclaimed group exhibition a point in space is a place for an argument at the gallery in 2007.
She has been a partner at David Zwirner since 2002, having joined in 1998.
Artists included in the show: Tomma Abts, Francis Alÿs, Bernd and Hilla Becher, Carol Bove, Marcel Duchamp, Morgan
Fisher, Robert Gober, Rodney Graham, On Kawara, Ruth Laskey, Sherrie Levine, Gordon Matta-Clark, John McCracken, Bruce
Nauman, Cady Noland, Jim Nutt, Thomas Ruff, Ed Ruscha, Alan Uglow, Christopher Williams, Mason Williams, Martha Wilson